I experienced two entertainments this weekend whose central theme was cloning, one a literary novel and one a blockbuster summer movie. One of these is theoretically "high brow" and one "low," which has started me thinking some about culture. I’ve moved Nobrow: The Culture of Marketing, the Marketing of Culture to the top of the To Read pile.
Friday night we went to see the summer movie The Island with our visiting friends, Rachel and Robin Bordoli, and Aaron Cheatham. The movie was much more scary than I expected from a PG-13 movie, but I think that’s just another sign that I’m getting older. It was definitely entertaining, and surprisingly thought provoking. It had excellent visual montages and settings of beautiful contemporary architecture, and the luscious Scarlett Johansson. As with almost all movies these days, it could have been edited more tightly, perhaps down 10-15 minutes (another sign I’m getting old). I liked the clean, crisp, well-lit visuals. There was several good chase scenes that caused actual flinching at several impacts, but when Ewan McGregor gets on a flying motorcycle, my brain is transported into Star Wars and my willing suspension of disbelief was broken. But it was a good seed for a lively conversation about cloning, definitions of personhood, chattel property, slavery, and immortality — which is more than I usually get from a summer movie.
Yesterday I read Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro, who also wrote Remains of the Day (and several other works. Like The Dogs of Babel, you read along for awhile before you figure out what’s going on — which is actually the same as what’s going on in The Island. The narrator has a deliberately plain voice as she recounts stories of maturing in a boarding school setting with other clones who are to be used for organ transplants, but don’t seem to realize the implications of that. Death is called "completion." The eerie thing about Never Let Me Go is that it’s set in late 1990’s England, implying that these programs are already secretly underway.
Definitely still thinking about what it means to be a person..